Surfin' Spoon
A beloved Nags Head frozen yogurt and ice cream sandwich shop with a genuinely great backstory — opened in a historic building in 2012 by a former pro surfer and his wife, survived a two-foot Hurricane Matthew flood in 2016, and came back stronger in a new building in 2021. Frozen yogurt bar, housemade ice cream sammies, and a warm community vibe that's hard to fake. One of those OBX spots you find yourself coming back to every trip.